Special Guardianship Orders vs Care Orders: Understanding the Key Differences for Families

child care

A Guide for Parents, Family Carers and Kinship Caregivers in England.

When a child cannot safely be cared for by their parents, the court may need to decide how their future care should be arranged. A Special Guardianship Order (SGO) and a Care Order are two different legal arrangements. Both can provide long-term stability, but they place responsibility in different hands and involve different levels of local authority oversight and support.

The central distinction is this: an SGO places primary responsibility for the child’s upbringing with the special guardian, whereas a Care Order gives the local authority parental responsibility and an ongoing role in planning, supervising and reviewing the child’s care.

What Is a Special Guardianship Order?

A Special Guardianship Order is a private law order under the Children Act 1989 which appoints one or more people, other than the child’s parents, as special guardians. It may be made in private family proceedings or at the conclusion of care proceedings. It is intended to provide a secure and stable home until the child reaches the age of 18 without legally ending the child’s relationship with their birth family. It is therefore not the same as adoption.

Before making an SGO, the court must receive a local authority report assessing whether the proposed guardian is suitable to meet the child’s needs. This is an important safeguard because special guardianship is a substantial long-term commitment and not simply an informal arrangement between relatives.

What Is a Care Order?

A Care Order is a public law order made under section 31 of the Children Act 1989. The court must first be satisfied that the child is suffering, or is likely to suffer, significant harm attributable to care falling below what it would be reasonable to expect a parent to provide, or because the child is beyond parental control.

Satisfying this threshold is a prerequisite to the making of a Care Order, but it does not follow automatically that such an order will be made. The court must still consider whether a Care Order is necessary and proportionate for the child.

A Care Order places the child in the care of the local authority. The authority determines where the child should live, whether with foster carers, approved family members, residential accommodation or, in some cases, with a parent. The legal order and the child’s physical living arrangements are therefore separate issues.

Who Makes Decisions About the Child?

Under a Special Guardianship Order

Parents who hold parental responsibility retain it. However, the special guardian can generally exercise parental responsibility to the exclusion of others who hold it, apart from another special guardian.

This enables the guardian to make most day-to-day and significant decisions about matters such as education, healthcare and the child’s upbringing without requiring parental agreement.

Parents should, where appropriate, be consulted regarding significant decisions affecting the child, although consultation does not confer a right of veto.

The special guardian’s authority is not unlimited. For example:

  • Changing the child’s surname requires either the consent of all persons with parental responsibility or the permission of the court.
  • Taking the child abroad for more than three months similarly requires consent or the court’s permission.
  • Any existing court orders or statutory restrictions must continue to be observed.

An SGO should therefore not be viewed as conferring unrestricted authority over every aspect of a child’s life.

Under a Care Order

The local authority shares parental responsibility with parents and others who already hold it. Parents do not lose their legal status as a parent.

However, the local authority may determine the extent to which a parent is able to exercise parental responsibility where this is necessary to safeguard and promote the child’s welfare. The authority must take account of the wishes and feelings of both the child and parents and remain within the legal framework governing care proceedings.

A Care Order is therefore not a licence for the local authority to disregard the family.

How Much Involvement Does the Local Authority Have?

A child who is subject to a Care Order is a looked-after child. There will usually be:

  • Ongoing social work involvement;
  • A care plan setting out future arrangements;
  • Regular looked-after child reviews;
  • Oversight from an Independent Reviewing Officer (IRO).

The local authority retains continuing statutory responsibilities in relation to the child’s accommodation, welfare and overall care planning.

By contrast, where an SGO is made, the special guardian assumes the primary parenting role. The child is no longer ordinarily subject to the looked-after child framework simply because an SGO exists. This greater family autonomy is one of the defining features of special guardianship.

Special guardianship should not, however, be confused with fostering under a different name. The legal framework and support arrangements are distinct.

What Financial and Practical Support Is Available?

The available support differs significantly between the two arrangements.

Where a child is placed under a Care Order with approved foster carers or kinship foster carers, fostering allowances and the wider professional support framework may apply. However, a Care Order does not automatically entitle every carer to fostering payments. The nature of the placement and the status of the carer remain important considerations.

Under an SGO, financial support is not automatic. Special guardianship allowances are commonly subject to assessment, means-testing and periodic review.

Families should not assume that fostering allowances will continue unchanged following the making of an SGO.

Before agreeing to an SGO, prospective guardians should obtain written clarity regarding:

  • Financial support and allowances;
  • Review arrangements;
  • Therapeutic or specialist services;
  • Support with family contact arrangements;
  • Assistance if the child’s needs become more complex in the future.

The key issue is not merely whether support is available in principle, but whether the proposed arrangements are clearly defined, adequately funded and realistically capable of meeting the needs of the particular child and household.

Can These Orders Be Challenged or Ended?

Both an SGO and a Care Order usually remain in force until the child reaches the age of 18 unless discharged earlier by the court. However, the process for challenging each order is different.

Discharging a Special Guardianship Order

A parent wishing to apply to discharge an SGO must first obtain the court’s permission.

Under section 14D of the Children Act 1989, permission cannot be granted unless the court is satisfied that there has been a significant change in circumstances since the order was made.

Demonstrating a significant change in circumstances does not automatically result in the court granting permission, nor does it mean the order will ultimately be discharged. These are separate stages of the process.

Discharging a Care Order

Under section 39 of the Children Act 1989, a Care Order may be discharged upon the application of:

  • A parent;
  • Any person with parental responsibility;
  • The child; or
  • The designated local authority.

This is not subject to the same permission requirement that applies to parents seeking to discharge an SGO. However, restrictions can apply to repeat applications, particularly where a previous discharge application has been made within the preceding six months.

As with any children’s case, the court’s paramount consideration remains the child’s welfare.

Which Arrangement Is Best for the Child?

Neither order should be regarded as inherently superior to the other.

Special guardianship offers a different balance between family autonomy, long-term responsibility and state support than the continuing local authority framework that exists under a Care Order.

The suitability of an SGO depends on:

  • The special guardian’s ability to meet the child’s needs;
  • The stability of the proposed placement;
  • The support available to the family;
  • The child’s long-term welfare requirements.

For families considering either arrangement, the key practical questions are:

  • Who will make decisions about the child?
  • What support is available if difficulties arise?
  • What financial assistance has been confirmed in writing?
  • How will the arrangement meet the child’s needs over time?

Understanding the answers to those questions is often more valuable than focusing solely on the title of the legal order.

Key Takeaway

A Special Guardianship Order places the special guardian at the centre of the child’s upbringing, giving them primary responsibility for day-to-day decision-making and care.

A Care Order places the child within the local authority’s continuing care framework, with ongoing oversight, care planning and statutory responsibilities.

Both are important legal arrangements designed to safeguard children and promote stability. Families should obtain specialist legal advice before agreeing to proposals, applying for an order, or seeking to challenge an existing arrangement.

This article provides general information about arrangements in England and is not a substitute for legal advice on an individual case. The law and support arrangements may differ elsewhere in the United Kingdom.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

nine − 1 =